The market for polymer striker-fired handguns is vast and diverse, catering to a wide range of preferences and needs. While naysayers contend they are all just versions of each other with no real differences, that’s not entirely true. Sure, there are similarities, primarily in basic function and look, but just like all 1911s share the same general mechanics and aesthetics, there are differences between them. Among the top contenders in the field, the Springfield Echelon, Glock 17, and Beretta APX stand out as popular choices for law enforcement and civilian gun enthusiasts. Let’s do a detailed comparison of these firearms, examining their similarities, differences, handling characteristics, capacity, MSRP, reliability, and aftermarket support.
Similarities
- Caliber Options: All three handguns come chambered in the 9x19mm cartridge, one of the most widely used pistol calibers globally.
- Polymer Frames: All three models feature polymer frames, which make them lightweight and durable, ideal for extended use.
- Striker-Fired: The Glock 17, Beretta APX, and Springfield Echelon all operate on a striker-fired mechanism, offering consistent trigger pull and quick reset, aiding in rapid and accurate follow-up shots.
Differences
Design and Ergonomics
- Springfield Echelon: The Echelon boasts a unique, aggressive grip texture and an ergonomic, contoured frame, offering excellent control and comfort. Its aesthetics are more streamlined and futuristic compared to the other two.
- Glock 17: Known for its utilitarian design, the Glock 17 prioritizes simplicity and reliability over aesthetics. Its grip angle is distinctively Glock, which some users love for its familiarity.
- Beretta APX: The APX takes a more modern ergonomic approach with interchangeable backstraps to suit different hand sizes. Its grip design is more contoured than the Glock but less aggressive than the Echelon.
Capacity
- Springfield Echelon: The Echelon typically offers a 17+1 round capacity, standard for most full-sized 9mm handguns
- Glock 17: The Glock 17 also offers a 17+1 round capacity, aligning with industry standards.
- Beretta APX: The Beretta APX stands out with a slightly larger 18+1 round capacity, giving it an edge in firepower.
MSRP
- Springfield Echelon: As of my last update in September 2021, the Echelon had an MSRP ranging from $599 to $699, depending on the variant and features.
- Glock 17: The Glock 17 is known for its affordability, with an MSRP typically under $600, making it one of the most budget-friendly options.
- Beretta APX: The Beretta APX had an MSRP in the same range as the Springfield Echelon, varying between $525 and $725, depending on the model and features.
Reliability
- Springfield Echelon: While the Springfield Echelon has been praised for its reliability and durability, it doesn’t have the decades-long track record of the Glock 17.
- Glock 17: The Glock 17 is renowned for its legendary reliability, earning the trust of law enforcement agencies worldwide.
- Beretta APX: The Beretta APX, although a relatively newer entrant, has been well-received for its reliability, with many users reporting minimal malfunctions.
Aftermarket Support
- Springfield Echelon: Springfield Armory has a growing aftermarket support system that may not be as extensive as Glock’s.
- Glock 17: The Glock 17 enjoys unparalleled aftermarket support, with countless accessories, parts, and customization options.
- Beretta APX: While less extensive than Glock, the APX’s aftermarket support has been expanding, offering more choices for customization and upgrades.
Handling Characteristics
The handling characteristics of these handguns can significantly impact the shooter’s experience:
- The Springfield Echelon’s aggressive grip texture and ergonomic frame make it comfortable and controllable, but it may not suit everyone’s preferences.
- The Glock 17’s simplicity and no-nonsense design make it easy to use, but some find its grip angle less comfortable than the others.
- The Beretta APX strikes a balance between the two, offering customization options to cater to various hand sizes, improving its overall handling.
Parting Shots
The Springfield Echelon, Glock 17, and Beretta APX are formidable choices for professional and civilian users. The right choice among these firearms depends on individual preferences, priorities, and requirements.
The Springfield Echelon offers a futuristic design, aggressive grip texture, and reliable performance. Its unique features and ergonomic advantages justify its slightly higher MSRP.
The Glock 17 is a time-tested, reliable workhorse known for its simplicity and affordability. It’s an excellent choice for those prioritizing reliability and ease of use over aesthetics.
The Beretta APX stands out with its interchangeable backstraps, increased magazine capacity, and competitive pricing. It’s a solid option for those who appreciate customization options and modern design.
Ultimately, the ideal choice depends on your specific needs and preferences. To make an informed decision, it’s crucial to test these firearms at a range, considering factors like ergonomics, recoil control, and accuracy, in addition to the criteria discussed in this comparison. Always prioritize safety and training when using firearms, regardless of your choice.
ABOUT THE AUTHOR:
David Workman is an avid gun guy and a contributing writer to several major gun publications. As an NRA-certified instructor, David trains new shooters on basic handgun skills and CCW requirements and is a strong advocate for training as much as possible. “Real-life shootouts don’t happen at a box range.”
You may also enjoy these popular articles:
Follow us on Social Media:
©MTC Holsters, LLC and CrossBreed Holsters Blog, 2023.
Unauthorized use and/or duplication of this material without express and written permission from this site’s author and/or owner is strictly prohibited. Excerpts and links may be used, provided that full and clear credit is given to David Workman and the CrossBreed Blog with appropriate and specific direction to the original content.